John Wiseman (18 February 2010)

I booked lunch for our 46th wedding anniversary and wanted it to be something special. A bitterly cold dismal day on the drive to Bakewell was offset as soon as we entered the Rutland Arms. The traditional comfortable English decor was relaxing and the politeness and professionalism of the staff was impressive. The dining room was warm, stylish and comfortable with a grand array of antique clocks adorning the walls. The wine was well presented and chilled and our starters were superb. The main course - chicken breasts were beautifully arranged and the sauce really exceptional. Everything was cooked to perfection and the whole meal spoke to me that the chefs were a cut above. Sweets were mouth watering and my wife had chosen the pear and almond tart very cleverly made to resemble a pork pie - I was impressed! All in all, a superb and enjoyable occasion for us and we will be returning. The redeeming impression was that the Rutland Arms has found that rare thing in this day and age - the right balance. Clever chefs, professional, friendly and courteous staff and a relaxed warm and tasteful environment! As I understand it, the Rutland Arms is still privately owned and as such, things haven't been messed around with. It is a gem and I really hope that it never falls into the hands of a group or chain. Thank you for a wonderful day!